Looking at the photo book, two competitors stand out: Mixbook and Shutterfly. Both companies offer a wide range of products and services, but it can be difficult to decide which option is better for you. The purpose of this article is to compare these two units and help you make an informed decision.
Mixbook turns out to be our favorite photobook service, narrowly beating out Shutterfly. Both platforms are great at offering great photo books and products. However, Mixbook comes out on top by offering a more user-friendly experience when creating and customizing photo items. The differences are subtle, but ultimately Mixbook takes the lead.
Looking for the best photo book service? Read our comparison of Mixbook vs Shutterfly to find out which one offers the best customization options, ease of use, and value for money.
A top-quality photo book service with a wonderful collection of templates and custom features.
Mixbook vs Shutterfly: What Do They Provide?
Mixbook and Shutterfly’s main focus is on creating personalized photobooks. These books act as customized compilations of your selected photos, similar to traditional photo albums, but with advanced personalization features. In particular, users will be able to incorporate different themes and color schemes, and will be able to control the placement of photos within the book.
Beyond photobooks, both platforms are expanding their offerings to include a wider range of personalized products. For example, Mixbook offers customizable cards for different occasions. Additionally, we offer home decor products such as calendars, posters, and canvas prints. Similarly, Shutterfly has diversified its portfolio, offering a variety of personalized items in addition to photobooks.
Shutterfly stands out for its wide selection of photography products, offering a variety of choices beyond traditional items. As well as cards and calendars, the range also includes unique options such as personalized puzzles, glitter blocks and metal prints. Shutterfly goes beyond the traditional by allowing customers to print photos on unconventional items such as picnic blankets, beach towels, and a variety of photo drinkware such as mugs and water bottles.
Shutterfly stands out for the breadth of products it offers, but the focus of our review is to find out which company makes the best photo books. This important evaluation is discussed in the next section.
Mixbook vs Shutterfly: Which Photo Book is Better?
Check out Mixbook and Shutterfly’s photo collections. Compare the templates provided. Let’s take a look at the editing options for each site. We also compare print quality and price.
The Photo Book Templates
Mixbook offers a wide selection of photobook templates with 230 options for family, 180 for everyday, 91 for travel, and 72 for weddings. Despite the wide variety, some users may find the templates to be slightly repetitive when navigating the extensive catalog. The designs are generally classy and elegant and cater to a variety of tastes.
In contrast, Shutterfly offers a cleaner collection of templates with fewer options for categories like family, weddings, and travel. However, the templates are all different, eliminating the potential browsing fatigue that comes with having more choices. One of Shutterfly’s unique selling points is its designer collection of books created by notable figures, adding an extra level of sophistication. Notable options such as the Disney Family Adventure Photo Book cater to specific interests, but come at a higher price point.
When evaluating both platforms, users can weigh Mixbook’s rich diversity against Shutterfly’s more curated and unique designs, taking into account personal preferences and potential for template repetition.
Mixbook beats Shutterfly when it comes to ease of use for creating photobooks. Both platforms offer similar basic options when it comes to layout and page format, but Mixbook’s interface is much more intuitive and comfortable. The drag-and-drop system for adding photos is quick to understand, and the customization tools are clearly labeled and easily accessible, ensuring a streamlined and efficient experience.
In contrast, Shutterfly’s interface has been criticized for being clunky and confusing, especially when it comes to creating photobooks. The process is more complicated, the pages lack the vibrant colors of his Mixbook, and the overall user experience suffers. Computer-savvy users may find both platforms easy to use, but Mixbook is the more user-friendly option for users who find computers difficult, especially in the main Mixbook and Shutterfly groups.
Ultimately, Mixbook’s focus on an easy-to-navigate interface contributes to a more positive user experience, especially for non-tech savvy users. The platform’s intuitive design and accessibility make it the perfect choice for creating personalized photo books.
Personalizing and Editing Photos
Mixbook and Shutterfly allow users to enhance their photobooks by editing backgrounds, stickers, text, and images. Shutterfly offers a wide selection of backgrounds, and there are plenty to choose from. Mixbook, on the other hand, has fewer options but focuses on subtlety and flavor with a personal touch. Shutterfly offers a variety of stickers featuring hearts, stars, and cars, as well as a variety of clip art options for additional customization. When it comes to text and image editing, Mixbook is the leader in ease of use. Both platforms allow users to add text, but Mixbook provides a smoother experience.
When it comes to image editing, Shutterfly offers basic features like cropping, rotation, and a limited number of filters. In contrast, Mixbook offers a more comprehensive selection of photo editing tools, including sepia, black and white, 80s filters, and adjustment effects such as saturation and brightness. While Mixbook’s tools don’t reach the level of complexity of professional software like Adobe Photoshop, they are flexible enough to enhance your photo book based on your preferences.
Photo Book Printing Options
When it comes to printing options, Shutterfly takes the lead by offering a more comprehensive product compared to Mixbook. While Mixbook offers three size options (8.5 x 8.5 inches, 10 x 10 inches, and 12 x 12 inches), Shutterfly offers six book sizes to choose from, giving users more flexibility.
Shutterfly introduces three different page types and Mixbook offers Second. However, Mixbook provides a more detailed description of page types to help users understand their selections more clearly, specifying semi-gloss or premium matte layflat pages. Shutterfly, on the other hand, uses terms like standard page, standard layflat page, etc. Flat and deluxe layflats do not have the same level of detail.
Both companies offer layflat books, a valuable feature for improving presentations. Mixbook stands out by offering more cover options, including softcover, hardcover, glossy hardcover, and matte soft-touch hardcover. Shutterfly offers soft and hard covers, but they also offer premium leather covers that give it a luxurious feel, but at a significantly higher price. Various coverage options allow users to choose based on both aesthetic preference and budget.
When comparing the print quality of Shutterfly and Mixbook, there is little difference between them. Print quality is an important factor when choosing a photo book company, and both Shutterfly and Mixbook have delivered satisfactory results.
While there are occasional concerns with his other Shutterfly products that the quality of the photos can be dark or saturated, the Shutterfly Photo Book boasts excellent image quality. The book is well bound and looks impressive, although the premium leather options may be a bit pricey.
Mixbook also has excellent print quality, delivering bright, clear photos with accurate colors. Users have not reported any issues such as image spots or defects. Mixbook’s flexible cover and binding options allow users to create exactly the book they want. Overall, both companies have performed very well in delivering high quality end products.
Photo Book Prices
Price-wise, Shutterfly vs Mixbook start at similar prices, around $20 for a softcover book with minimal format glossy pages. Mixbook prices increase gradually as book size or paper type changes, providing a more predictable cost structure.
Shutterfly, on the other hand, significantly increases prices when paper types and cover options change, resulting in a significant increase in the cost of the most expensive books, with the exception of the leather cover option. Mixbook has proven to be a more budget-friendly option for photography projects, offering competitive prices without unexpected spikes. Both companies offer satisfying end products, but Mixbook is a more affordable option for users who want to create a personalized photo book.
In the Mixbook vs Shutterfly debate, Mixbook emerges as the preferred option. Both companies offer great photo books, but Mixbook stands out with its intuitive and easy-to-understand interface. Creating a photo book on Mixbook is said to be easy, with the platform’s user-friendly design improving the overall experience.
While Shutterfly offers a broader range of features and a larger collection of templates and decoration options, Mixbook’s slimmer, easier-to-use interface and better value for money influence our final recommendation . Mixbook offers similar print quality to Shutterfly at a lower cost, making it an attractive option for those looking for a high-quality photo book at an affordable price. In summary, Mixbook is recommended as the preferred option for creating personalized photo projects.
Contact us if you have any questions.
Moreover, Don’t forget at VincentColor we provide Real Estate Photo Editing Service only from 0.5$